My White, Rural Town

 Hello everyone, and welcome back. I've yet again read another installment of Michelle Alexander's The New Jim Crow, and it's been educational to say the least. Today, I'd like to talk about some of the concepts discussed in her book, and relate them to my own life. 

In the interest of transparency, I'll admit that this morning, I didn't intend for this blog post to be based on my own "narrative." However, I ended up having a very insightful AP Language class midway through the morning, and found that it fit well with many of the themes of my book. We read a letter written by one of my school's alumni- it was about how he comes from a "small, white, rural town," but that just because of this, he shouldn't be exempt from basic human decency. One's background does not justify racism; this is a realization I've increasingly come to. 

Although my school is small and has little diversity, I've always considered it to be relatively "forward" in its thinking. I've always looked at examples of prejudice and bigotry within school systems and thought, "this does not apply to me." However, after reading the previously referenced letter, I've rethought this evaluation. The author brought up various examples of racism (and/or simple ignorance) throughout his education, and I found myself relating to many of them. For example, I myself remember having a 9th-grade debate about whether slavery was "good" or "bad," during which the entire class would regularly burst into giggles. The class clown would play devil's advocate, and in a low and humorous voice announce that the practice was "good for the economy." I felt extremely uncomfortable, but wondered if I was being too "sensitive," as no one else seemed to mind. Thinking back, that entire discussion was wildly inappropriate. 

My school is extremely tailored to the white experience. All of the topics we discuss are told from the white perspective, and because of this, social and historical issues often have an "us versus them" feel. There are no black students in my grade, but there are black students in my school. I often wonder how they felt during the "slavery talks," or during the race units. Because honestly, how arrogant is it for a room of white individuals to have a genuine discussion about whether or not it's ok to say the n-word, or to refer to enslaved peoples as a simple by-product of white history? This isn't entirely the fault of my school alone- my school didn't write the curriculum, or design the AP college board prompts. As Alexander discusses, nearly everything in society is constructed for the white audience, from movies and books to clothing and makeup; education is not the exception (172).

As a society, it is so incredibly important that we work towards unity, and move away from racism and prejudice. In class today, we also read about a bill that was proposed in the state of New Hampshire about a month ago. It would ban the classroom discussion of "divisive topics," which include race and sex. The fact that this bill might possibly pass (and within my high-school experience) is incredibly alarming. 

I have learned so, so much during my current unit on race, a unit that would be banned should this bill pass. As a society, we are still very racist. As I've learned from Alexander's book, we are using mass incarceration as a way to control the black population. As I've learned from the media, our law enforcement officers are shooting innocent black citizens on sight because of how they look. There is so much work that needs to be done, and so much action that needs to be taken. But none of that work or action is possible without education. 

Comments

  1. A powerful post, Juliet. I've had the same feelings of discomfort asking students to think about concepts of race and wondering how I would feel teaching this unit if there were a black student in the class because I wouldn't want them to feel targeted by the unit. Do you think it would still be a worthwhile unit if our school were more diverse? How would the unit have to change if the makeup of the class changed?

    ReplyDelete
  2. This was a very genuine post, Juliet. I too am taken aback by the "slavery debates" and with full honesty, didn't really question them until now. I think that this is partially due to this race unit, which has opened my eye to see the many aspects of race as well as my increased sense of maturity that has come these past two years. I completely agree with what you said in that it was wildly inappropriate. That aside, I'm curious as to what you think we should do different? Should we scrap the debate and still teach the history of slavery, or perhaps start the unit with an overarching intro to race prior to the debate?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Juliet!
    This was a very well-thought out post. Similar to you, I also reflected on some of my experiences throughout high school. The letter from the alumni was very eye-opening to me and made we realize that we are not excused from acts of racism just because we come from a small, white town. This entire race unit has really made me think about why, in the past, we had discussions about whether or not slavery was good or bad or whether it was okay to say the n-word or not. I also agree with what you said about the bill that might pass, banning us from learning about these divisive topics. It is crazy to think that people think we shouldn't learn about these major topics in history.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Kally!
      I agree; this unit has been very eye-opening for me as well. I think that education is the only way to combat important issues such as race, and the thought of a bill banning "divisive" topics is a bit frightening to me.

      Delete
  4. Hey Juliet,
    This was a really great and interesting post, and I feel very similarly to you. Referring to the 9th grade debate, looking back on that is difficult to think that some classmates were arguing to defend slavery (not by choice, but still hard to hear). I also agree with what you said about how our society is based on a white perspective: makeup, movies, fashion, and education. Also, I really hope that the bill doesn't pass, because this unit in class has taught me a lot, and I think all students should be learning about this.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts