Drugs = Mass Incarceration?


 Hello everyone! Welcome (or welcome back)! For the past week or two, I've been reading The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness by Michelle Alexander. Today I'll be getting into the relevance of the book. Usually, when one describes the "relevance" of something, they're forging a connection between a topic and a current event. However, in the case of the section I most recently read, the topic is a current event. Alexander uses the second segment of her book to describe the depth of the prejudiced system that exists, and how it came to be. So, some of the specific examples or "connections" that I use might be from an early point in the book. 

The second segment of The New Jim Crow delves heavily into criminalization based on drug use. Drug charges (particular minor/trumped-up charges) played a large roll in the birth of America's system of mass incarceration. This was largely due to new search and seizure laws. Originally, law enforcement couldn't go on unwarranted "crusades," picking people off the street and searching them as they pleased; this would be a huge violation of rights. However, in 1968, after Terry vs Ohio, this changed. It was stated that if a police officer observed "unusual conduct" or believes someone to be "dangerous and engaged in criminal activity," the officer is entitled to conduct a search for the "protection of himself and others in the area" (63). This is known as the stop-and-frisk rule, and is still in action today. (I suppose that the frequency at which unwarranted searches still happen proves the relevance of this information.) This Supreme Court ruling made blatant discrimination easy. More and more black citizens were being singled out and asked for "consent" to raid their belongs- more often than not, this consent was given out of pure fear or intimidation. 

With the War on Drugs came the mass incarceration of many black citizens. As fear and intimidation ran rampant, the pressure to plead guilty increased, and their (largely white) prosecutors were left to decide their fate (87). Some of these (incarcerated) people were in for the most trivial charges and only spent a matter of months in the system- others spent years. I didn't matter. Upon returning to society, these individuals would be viewed as entirely different, their legal standing in the country forever changed. There's a chance that some of these people were either innocent or falsely arrested; however, as Alexander pointed out, many of them wouldn't be able to afford a lawyer, and therefore their case would never be reopened. It's a bit funny- earlier in the book, Alexander referenced the creation of the Fifteenth Amendment, which states that "the right to vote should not be denied on account of race" (29). Yet here were are in 2021- "5.2 Americans are barred from voting due to felony disenfranchisement laws," the vast majority of whom are black (Nellis). Perhaps we truly are living in the new Jim Crow. 

So, so many black Americans live in fear of "police harassment, retaliation, and abuse," and they have good reason (69). They know that the system is working against them; there have been too many "cautionary tales," and it truly seems as though no mistakes can be afforded. Just look at Breonna Taylor, who was innocently shot in the confines of her own apartment, or George Floyd, who was suffocated to death by an officer (Oppel). These two examples are obviously quite well known- they sparked a series of protests throughout the U.S. However, they are two of many. 

We live in a country ridden with racism and inequality, hidden as it may be. If Alexander's book has taught me anything thus far, it's this- we cannot simply watch these horrifying events unfold, and be silent and compliant. We need to work eradicate America's current racial caste system, and prevent one from ever forming again. 


Works Cited

Nellis, Ashley. "The Color of Justice: Racial and Ethnic Disparity in State Prisons." The Sentencing Project, 14 June 2016, www.sentencingproject.org/publications/color-of-justice-racial-and-ethnic-disparity-in-state-prisons/. Accessed 11 Mar. 2021.

Oppel, Richard A., Jr, et al. "What to Know about Breonna Taylor's Death." The New York Times, 6 Jan. 2021, www.nytimes.com/article/breonna-taylor-police.html. Accessed 11 Mar. 2021.


Comments

  1. Hi Juliet!
    I thought this was an amazing blog post that delves into many of the current day issues by supporting these events with information from your book. For my argumentative essay last semester, I wrote about abolishing the death penalty. In my research, I found a plethora of information about the unjust numbers of blacks in jail for petty crimes or in some cases, are innocent. A lot of attention has been brought to cases of police brutality where the victims were killed, but so many cruelties by the justice system fly under the radar. The stop and frisk rule is far too subjective and allows blacks to be unfairly targeted due to prejudices or stereotypes. Their innocent actions can be interpreted as "threatening" by anyone with a slight bias. The issue becomes that people, including police officers, act on this implicit bias. I would be very interested to see if your book uses any real life examples and how they would compare to the stories we see in the news today. I hope to read about more of your thoughts as you continue to read the book!
    Sincerely,
    Emma H.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You've taken an important message from the book. The relevance of some of your points is very clear. The stop and frisk rule has been a very controversial one, particularly in NYC. It would have been interesting to read a little more about that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I still find it interesting but mostly alarming that 5.2% of Americans are still totally shut out from voting in our country. Especially when most of them are African American. That statistic is really good at portraying the racial caste as a serious issue. I like the urgency in your last paragraph too. This kind of "search and seizure" methods the police and courts use to discriminate are unacceptable and quite disgusting. How do you suppose we combat this issue? I think for the most part besides the obvious police brutality in the news, this type of systemic racism goes unnoticed. I think educating the public and holding our courts accountable would definitely be solid start but how do you think we could fully eradicate this if even possible?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I also find the statistics to be quite startling. Honestly, I think that the best way to combat the issue is to bring attention to it. I've noticed that in today's society, things get done when they have extreme press and social media coverage. This puts pressure on institutions, and forces change. It's a true example of how democracy works, and is a way we can use our rights to shape our country into the place we want it to be.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts